I usually have no problem being outspoken. Except when this topic comes up; I have trouble finding my voice. I think it’s usually because the person I’m talking with doesn’t give me the chance, but also because I’d have to go into this whole big thing about my version, or my story. Sometimes, I just don’t have the energy, especially when I know my audience won’t really listen anyway. With that, I’m going to use this platform and dive right in with something that has been bothering me for several years.
I heard that August is Breastfeeding Awareness Month. This has always been a touchy subject for me with a lot of my friends and family because I don’t share their sentiments. On top of that, my feeding journey looked very different than those around me. I had always planned to try to breastfeed, but didn’t have the pressure to if it wasn’t working out for whatever reason. That approach in and of itself is not very “mainstream” these days.
Little did I know that Summer would make that choice easy for me when she was born with a cleft lip/palate. On her third day of life, we met with her plastic surgeon, who basically flipped out when she found out the doctor’s at the hospital forced me to breast feed her during our delivery stay and set us up to go home with the same method. In as nice a voice as possible, the surgeon told me I had been starving my baby. The most “natural” and “instinctual” thing you do as a mom, especially in those first few moments, is to feed your baby. But, those doctor’s and lactation consultants were on such a mission to force me to breastfeed for the sake of breastfeeding that they misadvised me and completely disregarded our individual situation, which required a different path (something we would become very used to). Needless to say, I was furious and embarrassed.
With the inability to suck and no way to latch, a special bottle was our only option. Her surgeon and pediatrician both supported us and with a surgery on the horizon, our main mission was to plump up our tiny newborn – using breastmilk or formula, it didn’t matter. Because of my milk supply, I knew I needed to give pumping a shot. But this meant pumping throughout the day, getting up in the middle of the night to pump, AND feed her each time. Separately. I was fortunate to have an insane milk supply (we actually had to buy another fridge/freezer to accommodate all the storage). Although I didn’t realize the work this would entail initially, I didn’t bat an eye at pumping. I was willing to do anything for Summer, as her journey the next few months was already going to be tough enough.
Let me tell you about pumping. I would pump every 2-3 hours the first couple weeks and each pumping would take about 20-30 minutes start to finish (getting it set up, pumping, and cleaning up). The schedule became more consistent after a few weeks and pumping would be required every 3-4 hours. Because I was getting 12+ ounces with each pump (not bragging, but I meant it when I said my supply was insane), I had to bag a lot of the milk and freeze it. Summer wasn’t eating nearly enough to keep up with me and according to my mom friends, I was producing liquid gold at an all-time rate, so I had to preserve it. I didn’t have enough storage containers to keep very much “fresh” milk in the fridge because I needed two bottles for each pumping cycle, 10-12 times a day. Unless I wanted to do dishes every 2 hours, I had to buy the storage bags and pop that milk in the freezer. I also had a labeling system for the freezer, so we knew which bags to grab in order to maximize our supply and freshness.
We invested in a bottle warmer a few days into this because otherwise it took too long to warm up a cold breastmilk bottle for Summer to eat. I loved that little warmer and it makes me smile thinking about how new parents will do anything to prevent hearing a newborn scream. On top of that, Summer’s bottles were $30 a piece and we added a sterilizer to this routine. I know some people skip this with their infant, but we needed it because it was very important to keep Summer’s mouth clean, since everything was exposed inside and we didn’t want any complications with her impending surgery. We did lots of sterilization of her bottles and my pumping equipment to keep everything sanitized.
It was always really confusing when doctors, or anyone for that matter, asked if she was formula-fed or breastfed. Ummm…neither? Breastmilk, bottle fed became my go-to phrase because I wasn’t sure how else to say that she drank from a bottle, but still got the credit for giving her breastmilk. People must have understood, or been scared to know more, because that reply usually satisfied them and no further prodding was done.
Although it required more time and effort, I never questioned what I was doing. It was no one’s fault that I/we were in this situation and we just knew this was what we had to do to make the best of it. This was our journey and I was proud of everything I did to feed her. Because of how at peace I was with this route, it made me comfortable in knowing I wasn’t meant to traditionally breastfeed and here’s why:
- Anyone could feed my baby. This is definitely my top reason. I love feeding babies and I know my family and friends do, too. As a pumping mom (and even if I wasn’t), I loved when someone asked if they could feed Summer. I got to do it all. the. time and I enjoyed the little break if someone else wanted to. If you solely breastfeed, no one else can help you and no gets that precious time with your baby. (Sometimes, I think breastfeeding moms loooooove this part of breastfeeding, which is weird to me.)
- That brings me to my next point. Dads don’t get to feed/bond. Every single breastfeeding mom that I’ve talked to has said this to me, “The bond is just so special. It’s magical.” That’s wonderful. But, just for a second, think about how that made ME feel. I medically couldn’t, but thanks for putting me down. I know many people who couldn’t breastfeed for various reasons, so it’s not exactly a great feeling to be automatically put-down by something you can’t control. Also, how do you think it makes your husbands feel? Not only did you get 9 months of special bonding time while you physically carried and spiriturally/emotionally connected with your baby, now you’re taking the feeding time away from your man too.
- You don’t EVER know how much your baby is actually getting. This part would literally drive me nuts, and sometimes I think it’s irresponsible. Are they cranky cuz they are still hungry? Are they crying because their tummy is upset from something I ate? Are they going through a growth spurt and my supply can’t keep up? Other than time spent on each boob, there is absolutely no way to measure how much milk your baby is getting at each feeding. With pumping, I was able to track everything on an app (how much I produced from each side, how much Summer ate and when, and I was able to identify trends based on growth and/or regression). Several breastfeeding moms I know had really small babies, developmentally delayed, or later developed unhealthy relationships with food, and I can’t help but wonder if it’s because they insisted on breastfeeding…
- It’s free. Yupp, I said it. Breastmilk is free and I was fiscally excited about that for a good 4 months.
- Feeding in public. This is perhaps the most controversial, but buckle up because I’m going there. I get anxious being out and about with my breastfeeding moms because I know what’s coming. Most act entitled and ignorant to any other opinion or person that might have to be involved in their feeding session, whether they choose to or not. I remember being out to dinner with a good friend, and as she was pulling her cover over her to feed her newborn, she asked me if I was comfortable. I wasn’t, but I knew I couldn’t say no. I absolutely hate feeling like everyone is watching us and I also felt a little envious at how easily she could transition her child from fussing to eating. When Summer and I were at a restaurant, I would have to pump before leaving or in the car, make sure I had a cooler with enough milk and bottles, ask the waiter for a cup of hot water, and then wait several minutes while the bottle warmed up. It was a whole process. I have never been fine with someone breastfeeding at a restaurant, but I know enough to not make it a big deal because I’d be hit with, “Well, how would YOU like to eat in a bathroom?” (my cousin has aggressively thrown that one my way) or, “Could you eat/breathe with a blanket over your head?” First of all, your baby doesn’t know where they are eating. I get a bathroom isn’t ideal, but I’ve had to pump in a high school locker room before, so you’re preaching to the choir here (not that you’d know that because you never asked). I just think it’s like most things in our society now a days – can we just respect everyone instead of being insulted that someone has a different opinion than you do? And I realize you might need to feed in public sometimes, but can you at least cover up?
- …which leads me to my next reason. I don’t want to see your boobs. And no, I’m not sexualizing your boobs. Everybody pees and poops, but we don’t do that in front of each other. Everyone has sex and that is an intimate moment that happens privately, too. Breastfeeding should be as well, especially if the “bond” is one of the main reasons you do it anyway. I’m not really comfortable with anyone breastfeeding in public (unless covered). You don’t HAVE to, so don’t give me that line. Would you be comfortable with me busting out my pump in the food court and watching it drip milk for 20 minutes into a bottle. No, because that would be weird. So, I feel if I have to cover up and go somewhere private, out of the respect for those around me, everyone should.
- Capturing the moment. Do you really need to document this? I’m pretty sure your child is never going to want to see pictures of your boob in their mouth eating. You might think it’s special, and it very well could be to you (this is the area that I have no experience in and cannot relate to it emotionally), but you honestly think they are going to feel warm and fuzzy if they see a picture of them like that? Please tell me if they do…
- Traveling. Jordan and I love to be out and about. We enjoy exploring and doing new things. We knew Summer would contribute to this piece of our family, not hinder it. I couldn’t just whip my boob out. I couldn’t just pull over on the side of the road and give her a minute to suckle and buckle her back up (this part is probably my most envious of traditional breastfeeding moms). No, I was often traveling on I-75 with my pump tugging at my boobs under a feeding cover to either relieve the pressure or make a bottle on our way to wherever we were going. My mom or Jordan were usually driving and sometimes we would just look at each other and bust out laughing. It was comical, really, passing huge trucks or people dressed nicely driving to work, while I was sitting in the front seat being milked like a cow.
- The only people who care about breastfeeding are those that are breastfeeding. Seriously. Think about it. Do you ever have any authentic conversations about feeding with anyone other than breastfeeding moms? Do you hear your parents talking about whether you were breastfed or not? If your children are beyond the toddler phase, is this something that comes up in conversation at poker night with your friends? Do your neighbors bring it up at the Friday night bonfire? Likely not.
- Bottle-fed babies are more resilient. I haven’t done an actual study on this, so I’m making a generalization, but hear me out. If your child drinks from a bottle, and is fed by different people, they are interacting with others more frequently than breastfed babies. So many exclusively breastfeeding moms have tried to switch their babies to a bottle and they won’t take them. Why would they? They’ve never had to adjust their method because whenever they want to be fed, it’s instantaneous. Those kiddos that drink from bottles learn to become more flexible and patient because they have to wait. Another example of this was a time when one of my friends was trying to wean her baby off the boob. She said she was trying to prevent the baby from requiring a bottle in the middle of the night and creating a bad habit. I kindly reminded her that her baby waking up in the middle of the night for a bottle is the exact same as the baby waking up in the night and needing milk from her boob. Initially oblivious, she thought for a second and was like, “Oh yeah, that’s true.” We are all going through the same milestones with our kids, regardless of how they are getting the milk, but sometimes breastfeeding moms seem so high and mighty and whether they mean to or not, tend to put us non-breastfeeding moms down.
So there you have it. My long list of why I don’t think typical breastfeeding moms are inclusive to other ways of feeding. I’m aware that it probably sounds like I’m bitter. I’m really not. My daughter was made for me and I really believe her medical situation helped me gain confidence in my feelings of this before I was even able to articulate them myself. Summer was a breastmilk, bottle fed baby until almost 5 months old. She had the best nutrients prior to her surgery and through recovery, but as we approached that 5 month mark, I started to dry up. I took this as a beautiful sign to let go. It was a little hard for me because I didn’t want it to seem like I was lazy, but I also didn’t want to intervene with special teas, regimens, and supplements. I stopped pumping, used up our freezer stash, and began the transition to formula. And guess what? She remained JUST as happy as before and I gained a lot more time on my hands.
I just feel like with most things, the outspoken minority overshadows the thoughts and feelings of the silent majority. Since few people ever give me the chance to communicate what I have to say concerning the matter, this is me asking them to listen to the “other” side. I honestly don’t care how ANY baby is fed, or what sacrifice the parents make to do so, because we ALL go through it one way or another.
Why is breastfeeding such a thing? I know I’m not going to change anyone’s mind and I’ve probably pissed a few people off with my words. I’m just speaking from my experience and thought maybe I could enlighten a few people with it. After all, aren’t we supposed to support each other? My bra was more supportive to me in those first few months than my other breastfeeding mom friends/family. I never needed approval, but I would’ve certainly appreciated listening ears. I’m grateful for my husband, mom, grandma, Aunt Beth, Chelsey, and Mellissa who truly did cheer me on in my, albeit it different, feeding journey. Their patience and understanding with me, their reassurance that I always had Summer’s best interest at heart, and their willingness to feed Summer my sticky, natural breastmilk from a special bottle, will always mean the world to me. It’s no surprise that these are the very people Summer is the closest to (back to that whole bonding thing, ya know…) and that is what matters most to me.